One of the greatest debates for tea lovers is on teapots vs tea kettles. Which of the two is best? When should you use a teapot and a tea kettle? Can either of the two be substituted for the other?
Is it just a difference in the design or are there more underlying differences that you should pay attention to? Well, we are here to set the record straight on what is essentially the Tea Wars – the differences between teapots and tea kettles.
Joyoushousehold.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
We understand where most of the confusion comes from when comparing a tea kettle and a teapot. They look similar and are sometimes made of similar materials.
Is there really a difference between a cast iron teapot and a cast iron tea kettle? The answer to that question is yes, and the most significant difference lies in the purpose of each appliance. A tea kettle is designed for heating water to brew tea, while a teapot is designed for steeping and serving the tea.
This also answers one of the longstanding questions in this debate: Which is better? You can’t really question whether one is better than the other when they serve different purposes. They are both indispensable when you’re looking to prepare a great cup of tea.
That said, there are tea kettles that are designed with infusers so that you can boil the water and brew the tea at the same time.
Unfortunately, that also means that you run a higher risk of over-preparation where either the temperature of the water is too high or you steep the tea for too long, which ruins the flavor.
Despite there being stovetop teapot models, they are just not well suited to handle the heavy duty work of boiling water. So while tea kettles can be substituted for teapots, the inverse doesn’t work that well.
The purpose of the appliance dictates the material it is made from. Since a tea kettle is designed for heating water, then it stands to reason that it must be made of a material that can withstand high temperatures.
To that end, there are enamel kettles, steel kettles, cast iron kettles, and copper kettles. Of course, there are subtleties that you should pay attention when choosing a tea kettle based on its material.
For instance, copper tea kettles conduct heat faster, so you can boil water at much lower temperatures. Unfortunately, they are easier to scratch and dent since copper is quite the soft material.
Teapots on the other hand are designed for steeping and serving tea. The purpose they serve is twofold, therefore they are designed to be both practical and presentable.
Teapots are made from glass, ceramic, stainless steel and cast iron. Like tea kettles, they each have their pros and cons, which makes it important to understand the considerations you should make when buying a teapot.
Another consideration to make when comparing the differences between a teapot and a tea kettle is the cost. During the purchase, you will find that they both have similar price ranges with minimal fluctuations.
However, when you consider the cost effectiveness, then a teapot comes out on top. Keep in mind that a tea kettle is used for boiling water, so you have to consider its energy consumption as an added cost, especially for electric kettles. Therefore, while there are minimal cost fluctuations in the initial purchase, there are vast differences in the long run.
However, as with any product in the market, there are exceptions to the norm. There are certainly some teapots that are less cost effective than tea kettles, especially teapots bought as antiques.
The tea culture has been around for decades, and while the traditions have been mostly maintained, there are items, especially teapots, that are lost in the river of history.
To maintain that history, the few antiques from decades ago that have made it to modern day times are often just stored without a need to use them for tea brewing.
Since tea kettles are designed for the heavy lifting, then they are certainly more durable than teapots. Teapots pursue form over function while tea kettles pursue function over presentation.
Therefore, you shouldn’t be surprised to find that tea kettles are more durable than teapots even if the materials used are similar. For instance, tea kettles used heavy duty stoneware while a clay teapot would be more delicate.
Cleaning is yet another consideration that should be made but is often overlooked. Teapots are significantly harder to clean than tea kettles.
A tea kettle is often just used for boiling water, therefore, the cleaning is not as demanding as it is for a teapot. Cleaning a teapot, on the other hand, is much more intensive.
You have to ensure that you pay attention not to damage the teapot, which can be quite brittle depending on the material used. This also means that machine washing is off the topic for some teapots. In fact, one of the main considerations to make when purchasing a teapot is whether it supports machine washing.
Additionally, you have to take note of the infuser, especially in cases where it is not removable. A removable infuser makes cleaning much easier than a non-removable one. More importantly, you have to ensure that there are no lingering flavors after use because it would affect the taste of any other tea brewed in the teapot.
In some cases, you have to relegate the teapot to a single purpose, even after cleaning because of the lingering flavor, such as when using a ceramic teapot.
As mentioned, a teapot’s functions are twofold – functionality and presentation. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that teapots are designed to look better than tea kettles.
Despite looking similar in shape, the designs are leagues apart. Sure, there are some tea kettles that are designed to look good, but those are few and far between.
A teapot is a measure of elegance. As with any food, presentation is a key part of the service when drinking tea, so you want a teapot that looks just as great as the tea tastes.
The similarities between tea kettles and teapots are few, but the differences are many. That should make it clear that they serve different purposes and neither can be chosen over the other. While it is possible to substitute one for the other, nothing beats specialization.
In fact, we would highly recommend that you buy both, especially if you are a tea enthusiast who understand that there is more to preparing tea than meets the eye.